I wanted to try Greenhopper for a very long time. I already have firsthand experience with Jira.
I like the tool a lot and hence I decided to install the standalone version of Jira on my machine and Install Greenhopper on top of it.
So, I went to the Jira website.
I installed a Standalone version of Jira (Trial version, free for 30 days). I wanted to use the sandbox, but since it asked for the credit card details, I preferred the standalone version! You may need to create an account with Atlassian to get the License keys, one for Jira and another for Greenhopper.
Created the projects
Created issues of various types for different projects
Configured the translations
Created different components
Created different releases.
Created a couple of tickets
The following are the findings:
After upgrading to greenhopper, it will ask for indexing of
database, which will migrate all the tickets and during this time, Jira won’t
be accessible.
Planning Board:
Pros: Will be good to use when the project is going to start.
This is mostly for, on the fly issue creation and assigning
it to a version.
Affects version, if already created, we cannot create the
same version with greenhopper.
Cons: As when the cards grow, it will be a lot tough to use.
Filters cannot be used here!!!
The cards get listed only based on the version/component etc ONLY if the fix version is populated [scheduled]
Rapid Board (Kanban)
Pros: Thank God!, with the Rapid board, filters can be created and used.
This is more flexible and the TO DO are listed in a more
organised way(Kanban).
We can set quick filters as buttons [eg: My Issues,
Component etc).
There are good charts for trends,
burndown charts and timelines...
Cons:It will look a lot more cluttered with the defects coming in.
Categorization of cards is not available
The gist of the project at any given point in time will be difficult to achieve
Rapid Board (Scrum – Coming Soon) :)
Scrum is a method of development where the focus is on
planning, committing and delivering time-boxed chunks of work called Sprints.
Presets are:
Story Points as column statistic
Two-week iterations (starting today)
Velocity (evidence-based scheduling)
Standard Quick Filters
Issues ordered by Rank
Columns: To Do, In Progress, Done
Scrum option coming soon
My Opinion:There are good charts for trends,
burndown charts and timelines... with the rapid board.
The same can be achieved with the current dashboard functionality along with the desired charts.
I couldn't find a specific usecase, to move towards
Greenhopper as the dashboard can be made self-sufficient.
With its amazing defect tracking features, I thought greenhopper would offer more. Looking forward for the Rapid board - SCRUM.
Overall the product has amazing quality. Wow! was the experience in installing and uninstalling Jira. There was not even one hiccup. Since I was accustomed to the features of Jira, figuring out the configuration was easy. But for some one new to Jira, it would be a bit difficult. The features wont be easy in predicting the sequence. Once you get a hang of it, it is a child's play!
2 comments:
Hello, I liked the way your observations are arranged.
Can you also please post on Opensource tools like JMeter for simulating load?
Hey Dixie,
Sure. Will respond to your request after evaluating the same.
Post a Comment